特级无码毛片免费视频播放,国产午夜亚洲精品久久,国产午夜精品理论片久久影院,内射巨臀欧美在线视频,精品伊人久久大线蕉色首页,亚洲色偷偷偷综合网,亚洲成在线aⅴ免费视频,亚洲444kkkk在线观看

The Cross-Class Similarity Determination of Trademarks for Lubricating Oil and Motorcycles Finally Leads to the Invalidation of 12-Year Registered Trademark by the Supreme Court in the Retrial!

June 18, 2021

Case Summary:

Huai'an Hairun Petrochemical Co. Ltd. (Hairun Company) applied for registration of the disputed trademark on goods "Industrial oil; Motor oil; Emulsifying oil; White oil; Solvent oil; Lubricating oil; and Fuel oil" and the like in Class 4, on June 6, 2005, and was approved on November 14, 2008.

Huaihai Holding Group Co. Ltd. (Huaihai Company) cited its prior trademark No. 4489518 "淮海HUAIHAI and device" registered on goods "Electric bicycles, Electric tricycles, Motorcycles" in Class 12 and trademark No. 313958 "淮海HUAIHAI江蘇徐州 (JIANGSU XUZHOU) and device" on goods "Motorcycles" in Class 12 and filed an invalidation application of the disputed trademark.

Upon examination, the Trademark Review and Adjudication Board (the TRAB) determined that the disputed trademark constitutes confusingly similar trademark to the cited trademark which were used on the same or similar goods. Thus, the disputed trademark was ruled to be invalid. Hairun Company was dissatisfied with the decision and filed an administrative litigation with the Beijing Intellectual Property Court, the court of first instance, requesting to revoke the TRAB’s decision. After examination, the Court announced that although the disputed trademark was composed of the character "淮海", which was completely contained in the two cited trademarks and constituted a similar trademark, the goods "Industrial oil; and Lubricating oil" and the like approved for use by the disputed trademark and the goods approved for use by the cited trademark had great distinctions in function, use, marketing channel and consumer group, and they did not constitute similar goods. The judgment of the first instance revoked the TRAB’s decision and maintained the disputed trademark. Huaihai Company appealed to the Beijing High People's Court, the court of second instance, but the court decided to uphold the judgment of the court of first instance.

Huaihai Company refused to accept the second-instance judgment and appealed to the Supreme People's Court for a retrial, and entrusted Unitalen to participate in the retrial proceedings on its behalf. Unitalen lawyers collected the relevant evidence and made arguments, which were finally adopted by the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court Judgment:

Both the courts of the first and second instances held that the lubricating oil and motor oil in Class 4 designated by the disputed trademark and the goods such as tricycles, and motorcycles in Class 12 designated by the two cited trademarks of Huaihai Company did not constitute similar goods, which did not violate Article 28 of the original Trademark Law. After the trial, the Supreme Court held that lubricating oil and motor oil are spare parts for tricycles and motorcycles, often sold in motorcycle parts markets or garages. The two were connected to a certain degree and determined as similar goods. The judgments of the first and second instances were revoked, and the original TRAB's ruling to invalidate the disputed trademark was upheld.

Typical Significance:

The retrial judgment in this case clarified that when determining whether the disputed trademark and the cited trademark constitute similar trademarks on similar goods, and whether it is likely to cause confusion and misunderstanding by the relevant public, in addition to the similarity degree of the trademark logo and the similarity degree of the goods, factors such as the distinctiveness and popularity of the cited trademark, as well as the subjective intention of the applicant for the disputed trademark should also be considered. Regarding the similarity degree of goods, even if the related goods belong to different classes in the Table for Differentiating Similar Goods and Service, they shall be determined as similar goods if they are used by collocation and are highly related in terms of function, use, consumer group, and marketing channels, etc. In the meantime, the relevant comments on the defense of stabilizing the market order in the retrial judgment are of reference significance for similar cases.

 

Keywords

主站蜘蛛池模板: 精品国产丝袜自在线拍国语| 亚洲欧美综合一区二区三区| 国产亚洲精品久久久美女| 日韩av无码午夜免费福利制服| 国产偷国产偷亚洲清高| 无码高潮又爽又黄a片日本动漫| 欧美精品无码久久久久久| 韩国 日本 亚洲 国产 不卡| 国产亚洲另类无码专区| 亚洲免费鲁丝片| 国产欧美日韩在线在线播放| 一本一道色欲综合网| 欧美人成视频在线视频 | 国产欧美日韩在线观看一区二区 | 在线综合亚洲欧美网站| 亚洲欧美丝袜精品久久中文字幕| 狠狠色丁香婷婷亚洲综合| 熟妇人妻中文a∨无码| 久久国产福利国产秒拍| 国产亚洲精品久久久久久国| 老司机精品无码免费视频| 亚洲国产桃花岛一区二区| 玖玖玖国产精品视频| 动漫h无码播放私人影院| 久久综合综合久久综合| 欧美激情一区二区三区aa片| 男人j进入女人j的视频免费的 | 亚洲欧洲日韩在线电影| 国产裸拍裸体视频在线观看| 伊人久久精品在热线热| 男人的天堂在线无码观看视频| 国产福利一区二区精品秒拍 | 国产成人精品人人2020视频| 久久天天拍天天爱天天躁| 亚洲国产天堂久久综合226114| 国产无遮挡乱子伦免费精品| 国产av亚洲精品久久久久李知恩| 国产丝袜无码一区二区视频| 国产在线精品国偷产拍| 动漫av永久无码精品每日更新| 亚洲最新无码中文字幕久久|